atom06:Analysis

From student
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(→Network analyses)
 
(287 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
__TOC__
 
__TOC__
  
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; " >
 +
=Summary of analysis flow=
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
 +
[[atom06:Analysis#Objective analyses|'''Objective''']]
  
−
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
+
Analyses to form an understanding of the physical constraints and possibilities of the [[atom06:Project site | '''location ''']] on various scales
−
'''Objective'''
+
−
 
+
−
Initial analyses, objective site analyses to form an understanding of the physical constraints
+
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px;" >
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px;" >
−
'''Subjective'''
+
[[atom06:Analysis#Subjective analyses|'''Subjective''']]
−
Subjective analysis
+
 
 +
Analyses not solely based on raw objective figures, they are a perspective on how the different work and are connected.
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
−
'''Interviews'''
+
[[atom06:Analysis#Interviews|'''Interviews''']]
−
To create an initial starting point for the design intervention, we need to form a understanding of the actors and their networks relating to our site. At first we conducted interviews on the site and within identified main stakeholders.
+
−
</div>
+
  
 +
To create an initial starting point for the design intervention, we need to form a understanding of the actors and their networks relating to our site. At first we conducted interviews on the site and within identified [[atom06:Validators|main stakeholders]].
 +
</div>
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
−
'''Network'''
+
[[atom06:Analysis#Network analyses|'''Network''']]
−
Based on the interviews and research on plans for the area we identified a body of intermediators (see theory), on whose network we want to take a closer look.
+
  
−
We desided to use twitter(link) as a source of data, since many of the intermediators seem to have an active presentation in there. We want to explore the extent it is possible to actually utilise the attributes, and avatar network that the actors have already formed.  
+
Based on the interviews and research of plans and actors for the area we identified a body of [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actor-network_theory intermediators (wikipedia link to the actor-network-theory)], this type of analyzing data helped to organize the layers of information.
 +
 
 +
Analyzing activities per usergroup at different times and using Wikipedia and Twitter as sources of virtual data on existing communities.  
 +
</div>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
−
<div style="float:left; border:none; margin-right: 10px; clear: left; " >
+
<!----------- Objective analyses --------------->
−
=Network Analysis=
+
  
−
After an initial observation of the site, we carried out some analysis to understand the dynamics of our project's site.
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
−
We used a double cognitive approach, conducting two main types of analysis: objective and subjective.
+
=Objective analyses=
  
−
=Interviews=
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
[[File:Delft green & water copia.jpg |  240px| frameless | link=atom06:Objective analysis| Gathered data]]
 +
</div>
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
[[File:Atom 6 current actors WEEK DAY 1.jpg | 215px| frameless | link=atom06:Objective analysis| Gathered data]]
 +
</div>
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
Mapping the city in terms of traffic, history, green spaces and built area has provided a larger picture of the fabric in which the location is set; it exists between two systems, the TU campus and residential area. It is crucial to know the current actors in the area to make a decision on the importance of possible activities of various actors. This has been further analysed in the [[atom06:Network#Map_users_activities| network analyses]] as the mapping of user activities.
 +
</div>
  
−
=Initial analysis=
+
<div style=" float:left; width:250px; clear:right;  " >
 +
<div style="background:#999; color: #fff; font-family:Helvetica; padding: 10px; ">
 +
==Conclusion==
  
−
==Objective Analyses==
+
The site, De Vries van Heijstplantsoen, is an in-between space among two systems, the city system and the TU system.
  
−
<gallery widths="200" heights="150" perrow="4" >
+
It has strict and impermeable borders, and it blocks the pedestrian movement on the location.
 +
</div>  
  
−
File:Delft green & water copia.jpg|'''Morphological Analysis'''
+
See more on [[atom06:Objective analysis| Objective analyses]]
 +
</div>
 +
</div>
  
−
File:Districts' history and functionsmerge copia.jpg|'''Districts' Hystory and Analysis'''
+
<!----------- Subjective analyses --------------->
  
−
File:traffic2.jpg|'''Traffic Analysis'''
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
  
−
</gallery>
+
=Subjective analyses=
  
−
<gallery widths="200" heights="150" perrow="4" >
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; overflow:hidden; " >
−
File:Atom 6 current actors WEEK DAY.jpg|'''current residents week days'''
+
[[File:Flows typology merge copia.jpg | frameless | 270px |  link=atom06:Subjective analysis]]
 +
</div>
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; overflow:hidden; " >
 +
[[File:Green-spaces-options.png | frameless | 220px |  link=atom06:Subjective analysis]]
 +
</div>
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
The park paths' layout is protected. Keeping the layout but extending the greenery and pedestrian area, serves best the needs for connecting the site to immediate surroundings.
  
−
File:Atom 6 current actors WEEK DAY 1.jpg|'''current residents week days overall'''
+
Open water needs to be added for reasons of water security (flooding) and ecology (bats, wasteland ecologies). Water is also a natural entry barrier.
  
−
File:Atom 6 current actors WEEKEND.jpg|'''current residents weekends'''
+
Re-routing the highly trafficked roads removes the site from isolation and returns the park to work as a connecting entity between the Science Center and the faculty of architecture.
 +
</div>
  
−
File:Atom 6 current actors WEEKEND 1.jpg|'''current residents weekends overall'''
+
<div style=" float:left; width:250px; clear:right; " >
 +
<div style="background:#999; color: #fff; font-family:Helvetica; padding: 10px; ">
 +
==Conclusion==
  
−
</gallery>
+
Park is not used or known. Extending the hidden park to a city park serves the needs of residents and TU campus visitors.
  
−
the idea of mapping the current direct actors in the area is that we can decide on the importance of possible activities in the area at different times
+
A large campus park will work towards creating an image of TU Delft as a significant world class university and work as a gateway for visitors and as a place to relax for personnel and students alike.
  
−
figures are based on the [http://www.delft.nl/Inwoners/Gemeente_en_democratie/Cijfers_en_onderzoek/Statistisch_jaarboek/Meest_actuele_cijfers  most current statistical figures] from the city of Delft regarding education and residents
+
</div>
  
 +
See more on [[atom06:Subjective analysis| Subjective analyses]]
 +
</div>
 +
</div>
  
−
=Subjective Analyses=
 
  
−
<gallery widths="200" heights="150" perrow="2" >
 
  
−
File:Flows typology merge copia.jpg|'''Flows' Typology Analysis'''
+
<!----------- Interviews --------------->
  
−
File:Perceptive analysis merge copia.jpg|'''Perceptive Analysis'''
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
  
−
</gallery>
+
=Interviews=
  
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:490px; margin-right: 10px; overflow:hidden; " >
 +
<youtube width=470>HcBsTfV-NDE</youtube>
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:250px; margin-right: 10px; " >
  
 +
==Students & Teachers==
  
−
==Green Spaces and Roads Configurations==
+
Students live in the area and spend a lot of time next to or around the site during the week.
  
−
We analyzed some possible configurations of expansion of green spaces in relation to roads.
+
* nobody uses the space
 +
* would be a good place to meet, different from the (boring) standard of the TU everywhere else
 +
* has a lot of potential
  
−
<gallery widths="300" heights="150" perrow="6" >
+
</div>
  
−
File:Atom6 option0a.jpg|'''Option 1''' is to leave the boundaries as they are and work within the existing site. This means that the roads are there as a barrier.
+
<div style=" float:left; width:250px; clear:right; " >
 +
<div style="background:#999; color: #fff; font-family:Helvetica; padding: 10px; ">
 +
==Conclusions==
  
−
File:Atom6 option1a.jpg|'''Option 2''' is to get rid of the Mijnbouwstraat and extend the park to the Botanical gardens and the Science Center. This will allow for functions that relate to the Science center to be effectively connected and creates the possibility for us to connect to the Botanical gardens, for which they already have a path leading to the Plantsoen.
+
There is a desire that these two systems get more integrated and start to actively communicate and interact to create a better whole.  
  
 +
The interviews back up the initial striving for a city park from several perspectives.
  
−
File:Atom6 option2a.jpg|'''Option 3''' is to make the Julianalaan in front of the faculty of Architecture all park so the school connects better with the park and can really explore it's potential and connect with it for a new extension for it's need for space. The Botanical gardens and the Science Center will get even more traffic because of the 2-way traffic.
+
The campus lacks a place for recreational activities, between lessons and outside of curricula.
 +
</div>
  
−
File:Atom6 option3a.jpg|'''Option 4''' is to only close off part of the Julianalaan, creating only part of the Mijnbouwstraat 2-way traffic, as per plans from the city council and creating a park that partly extends to the faculty of architecture.
+
See more on [[atom06:Interviews| '''Interviews''']]
−
[http://www.google.nl/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CBsQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.tunoord.nl%2Farchief%2FOntwikkelingsplanTUnoordtbvbewoners041130.pdf&ei=MmF2Ts_DBIqb-gbrx7zSDA&usg=AFQjCNHs0cKMZVeLTYDpKt-YrpALxGBGyQ&sig2=IlM2XsYpAvJ39CUwuhtk1gdevelopment plan TU north, 2004]
+
</div>
 +
</div>
  
−
File:Atom6 option4a.jpg|'''Option 5''' is the 'radial' one where we close off both the Mijnbouwstraat and Julianalaan, redirecting traffic via the Zuidplantsoen behind the faculty of Architecture. This will create a space where the Science Center, the Botanical gardens, the faculty of Architecture and the roads beside the student housing at Michiel de Ruyterweg are bonded as one to create a large green space that (along with the botanical gardens) stretches all the way to the river de Schie. This would create a large usable park all involved parties, getting rid of the busy traffic and bond. Plus creating a green route for land traveling animals to get from the Schie to the cemetery and further.
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
  
−
File:Option 5a.jpg|'''Option 6''' is the 'radical extreme' where we divert the traffic around the burial grounds via the main library and Aula. This one big green space would be a main focal point and park for the whole area. Parking is solved by underground parking or 'closed stacked parking' at certain points. Behind the Science Center, DUWO is already planning on building one, with the help of the Science Center. This could also be done at Bouwkunde to improve the connection with all the green. We really need to also consider the house at the point of the current park at the Poortlandplein as it blocks the entrance to the park. In some way this could also be a plus, creating an enclave.
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
  
−
</gallery>
+
==Resident- Harry Koerts<br>.==
  
 +
* there is no connection between the residents and the TU
 +
* the park is a green enclave in the city, but nobody uses it as it's hidden between busy roads
 +
* in the evenings the park is unsafe
  
 +
* (future) student residents will probably see the park as their back yard
  
 +
[[atom06:Interviews#A_man_in_the_park_-_Harry_Koerts| '''Interview with Harry Koerts''']]
 +
</div>
  
 +
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
==Deflt City, Environmental office==
  
−
==='''Map users activities'''===
+
Diny Tubbing is the writer of the report [http://www.delft.nl/dsresource?objectid=58121&type=org Ecologieplan Delft 2004 - 2015], department of greenery of the city Delft
  
−
# Map the users
+
* Changing the roads
−
# Map their current & possible activities
+
* Extending the water structure
−
# Identify
+
* Park historical value & maintanance
−
# How to connect users
+
−
# Find matching activities
+
−
# Match the users by their activities / mix functions
+
−
# Connecting activities form the interaction and program
+
−
# The program (list of activities) is organised / mapped
+
  
−
Questions
+
[[atom06:Interviews#Deflt_City.2C_Environmental_office| '''Interview with Diny Tubbing''']]
−
# How does it change by the effect of users?
+
</div>
−
# How to map the users? Diagrammatically, with sensors etc.
+
  
−
Possible usergroups
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
−
# Students
+
==Gardener at the botanical gardens==
−
# Residents
+
−
# Science center (workers, visitors, ...)
+
−
# Architecture department (tutors, personnel)
+
−
# Botanical garden
+
−
# Duwo
+
  
−
<gallery widths="200" heights="150" perrow="3" >
+
* in the beginning there were plans to extend to the Vries van Heystplantsoen, but the city didn't want to cooperate
 +
* there even is a road going to the park, but now it just has a closed gate
 +
* the gardens host musical events and facilitate workshops
 +
* they sow into the community in that they also employ the handicapped
  
−
Image:Activities parameterized.jpg|'''mapping of activities per user group, optimizing the site program'''
+
[[atom06:Interviews#Gardener_at_the_botanical_gardens_-_Karel_Oberman| '''Interview with Karel Oberman''']]
 +
</div>
  
−
Image:Actor-relation copia.jpg|'''mapping of actor relations'''
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:240px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
==Director of the Science Center==
  
−
Image:Actor copia.jpg|'''mapping of activities per user group'''
+
* the busy Mijnbouwstraat is a real hindrance to the public
 +
* they feel separated from the TU because of the busy roads and the not-used park, they want to become ONE whole
 +
* there is no parking, so people have to park behind the faculty of Architecture
 +
* they want to expand
  
−
</gallery>
+
[[atom06:Interviews#Director of the Science Center - Michael van der Meer| '''Interview with Michael van der Meer''']]
  
−
[https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ar5AYZD5l2EfdE9nM01FVjZTc3BQMncwaTRmUkpScEE&hl=en_US#gid=0 editable user groups and their activities and needs - table]
+
</div> 
 +
</div>
  
−
on the basis of this table possible activities can be identified for the various users surrounding out site.
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width: 99%; overflow:hidden; margin: 10px auto 20px; " >
  
−
One thing that is also important is the time frame in which these activities go on. For example, in the evenings/weekends, students will not be there in large numbers, as such the program will need to adjust to whoever will be there, and to provide as needed.
+
=[[atom06:Network | '''Network analyses''']]=
  
−
'''On top of these we can provide optional additional activities for connecting the TU and the residents as the connection models require'''
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:300px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
[[File:Actor act sum up copia.jpg | frameless | 300px |  link=atom06:Network]]
 +
</div>
  
−
These two combined will provide us with a basis for our program on our site.
+
<div style="float:left; border:none; width:300px; margin-right: 10px; " >
 +
After the objective analyses and the subjective analyses, the goal is to gather information with the theoretical model (the actor-network-theory) in mind.  
  
 +
The result of these analyses are an understanding of how the current networks are related and function.
  
 +
From these findings the concept of connections and redistribution of the networks has been set
  
−
==='''Map city attractor points'''===
 
  
−
mapping the busy areas in Delft during the daytime throughout the '''week''' and the '''weekend''' shows us where there are good connection points for the possible metastasis objects to attract attention and real time connect to our center platform
+
The models of activities per usergroup are set up and show that there are matching activities per usergroup for the possibility for a better interaction on our location.
  
 +
</div> 
  
−
<gallery widths="200" heights="150" perrow="3" >
+
<div style=" float:left; width:250px; clear:right; " >
 +
<div style="background:#999; color: #fff; font-family:Helvetica; padding: 10px; ">
 +
==Conclusion==
  
−
Image:Business c.jpg|'''mapping of business in Delft during regular weekday daytime.'''
+
* Show that the two systems do not cooperate or interact on a physical level very well, while on a virtual level there are some connections.  
 +
* The mapping of activities show that there are several matches to increase interaction between various user groups
  
−
Image:Business d.jpg|
+
</div>
 +
<br style="clear: both; height: 0; line-height: 0; font-size: px; /*for IE*/"/>
  
−
Image:Business weekend.jpg|'''mapping of business in Delft during weekend daytime.'''
 
  
−
Image:weekend people.jpg|
 
  
−
</gallery>
 
  
  
 +
[[atom06:Home | '''<<Back to home''']]
  
 +
[[atom06:Challenge| '''to Challenge >>''']]
  
−
 
+
[[atom06:Concept| '''to Concept >>>''']]
−
=Conclusions=
+
−
 
+
−
The analysis reveals that our site is an in-between space among two system that don't cooperate and interact: City system - Tu system.
+
−
Our desire is that these two systems get more integrated and start to actively communicate and interact. We and some of the residents we interviewed feel this is needed to make the city unified again.
+
−
 
+
−
 
+
−
 
+
−
 
+
−
[[atom06:Home | '''Back to home >>''']]
+
−
 
+
−
 
+
−
</div>
+

Latest revision as of 16:19, 17 October 2011

<< Back

Contents


Summary of analysis flow

Objective

Analyses to form an understanding of the physical constraints and possibilities of the location on various scales

Subjective

Analyses not solely based on raw objective figures, they are a perspective on how the different work and are connected.

Interviews

To create an initial starting point for the design intervention, we need to form a understanding of the actors and their networks relating to our site. At first we conducted interviews on the site and within identified main stakeholders.

Network

Based on the interviews and research of plans and actors for the area we identified a body of intermediators (wikipedia link to the actor-network-theory), this type of analyzing data helped to organize the layers of information.

Analyzing activities per usergroup at different times and using Wikipedia and Twitter as sources of virtual data on existing communities.


Objective analyses

Gathered data

Gathered data

Mapping the city in terms of traffic, history, green spaces and built area has provided a larger picture of the fabric in which the location is set; it exists between two systems, the TU campus and residential area. It is crucial to know the current actors in the area to make a decision on the importance of possible activities of various actors. This has been further analysed in the network analyses as the mapping of user activities.

Conclusion

The site, De Vries van Heijstplantsoen, is an in-between space among two systems, the city system and the TU system.

It has strict and impermeable borders, and it blocks the pedestrian movement on the location.

See more on Objective analyses


Subjective analyses

Flows typology merge copia.jpg

Green-spaces-options.png

The park paths' layout is protected. Keeping the layout but extending the greenery and pedestrian area, serves best the needs for connecting the site to immediate surroundings.

Open water needs to be added for reasons of water security (flooding) and ecology (bats, wasteland ecologies). Water is also a natural entry barrier.

Re-routing the highly trafficked roads removes the site from isolation and returns the park to work as a connecting entity between the Science Center and the faculty of architecture.

Conclusion

Park is not used or known. Extending the hidden park to a city park serves the needs of residents and TU campus visitors.

A large campus park will work towards creating an image of TU Delft as a significant world class university and work as a gateway for visitors and as a place to relax for personnel and students alike.

See more on Subjective analyses



Interviews

Students & Teachers

Students live in the area and spend a lot of time next to or around the site during the week.

  • nobody uses the space
  • would be a good place to meet, different from the (boring) standard of the TU everywhere else
  • has a lot of potential

Conclusions

There is a desire that these two systems get more integrated and start to actively communicate and interact to create a better whole.

The interviews back up the initial striving for a city park from several perspectives.

The campus lacks a place for recreational activities, between lessons and outside of curricula.

See more on Interviews

Resident- Harry Koerts
.

  • there is no connection between the residents and the TU
  • the park is a green enclave in the city, but nobody uses it as it's hidden between busy roads
  • in the evenings the park is unsafe
  • (future) student residents will probably see the park as their back yard

Interview with Harry Koerts

Deflt City, Environmental office

Diny Tubbing is the writer of the report Ecologieplan Delft 2004 - 2015, department of greenery of the city Delft

  • Changing the roads
  • Extending the water structure
  • Park historical value & maintanance

Interview with Diny Tubbing

Gardener at the botanical gardens

  • in the beginning there were plans to extend to the Vries van Heystplantsoen, but the city didn't want to cooperate
  • there even is a road going to the park, but now it just has a closed gate
  • the gardens host musical events and facilitate workshops
  • they sow into the community in that they also employ the handicapped

Interview with Karel Oberman

Director of the Science Center

  • the busy Mijnbouwstraat is a real hindrance to the public
  • they feel separated from the TU because of the busy roads and the not-used park, they want to become ONE whole
  • there is no parking, so people have to park behind the faculty of Architecture
  • they want to expand

Interview with Michael van der Meer

Network analyses

Actor act sum up copia.jpg

After the objective analyses and the subjective analyses, the goal is to gather information with the theoretical model (the actor-network-theory) in mind.

The result of these analyses are an understanding of how the current networks are related and function.

From these findings the concept of connections and redistribution of the networks has been set


The models of activities per usergroup are set up and show that there are matching activities per usergroup for the possibility for a better interaction on our location.

Conclusion

  • Show that the two systems do not cooperate or interact on a physical level very well, while on a virtual level there are some connections.
  • The mapping of activities show that there are several matches to increase interaction between various user groups




<<Back to home

to Challenge >>

to Concept >>>
Retrieved from "http://vhpark.hyperbody.nl/index.php/atom06:Analysis"
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Projects
Atoms
Toolbox